Equity Bancshares Inc. (NASDAQ:EQBK) Q4 2022 Earnings Conference Call January 26, 2023 10:00 AM ET
Company Participants
Chris Navratil – Investor Relations
Brad Elliott – Founder, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Eric Newell – Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
John Creech – Chief Credit Officer
Craig Anderson – Executive Vice President and President-Equity Bank
Conference Call Participants
Jeff Rulis – D.A. Davidson
Andrew Liesch – Piper Sandler
Damon DelMonte – KBW
Terry McEvoy – Stephens
Operator
Good day and thank you for standing by. And welcome to the Fourth Quarter 2022 Equity Bancshares, Inc. Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Please be advised that today’s conference is being recorded.
I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Chris Navratil with Equity Bancshares. Please go ahead.
Chris Navratil
Good morning. And thank you for joining Equity Bancshares conference call, which will include discussion and presentation of our fourth quarter 2022 results. Presentation slides to accompany our call are available via PDF for download at investor.equitybank.com by clicking the presentation deck. You may also click the event icon for today’s call posted at investor.equitybank.com to view the webcast player. If you are viewing this call on our webcast player, please note that slides will not automatically advance.
Please reference Slide 2, including important information regarding forward-looking statements. From time to time, we may make forward-looking statements within today’s call and actual results may vary. Following the presentation, we will allow time for questions and further discussion. Thank you all for joining us.
With that, I’d like to turn it over to our Chairman and CEO, Brad Elliot.
Brad Elliott
Thank you, Chris. Good morning. Welcome to our fourth quarter earnings call, and thank you for your interest in Equity Bancshares. With me on the call today are CFO, Eric Newell; COO, Greg Kossover; President, Craig Anderson; and Chief Credit Officer, John Creech.
I want to start by celebrating two accomplishments. First, net income for 2022 was a company record totaling $57.7 million. Second, we had a record revenue totaling $197.8 million. Both achievements show the strength of our franchise, our success in serving our customers and showcase our talented group of employees. A year ago, we had expectations of rising interest rates, but no one was forecasting 400 basis points of increases from the Federal Reserve.
Our team’s work to prepare for this inevitable rising rate environment in 2020 and 2021 by keeping our loan pricing short. The results speak for themselves. Loan yields in the fourth quarter of this year were 123 basis points higher than last year, anticipating a challenging environment for raising and maintaining deposits. I mobilized the teams to refine our sales approach to find incremental ways we could do better.
We took the opportunity to focus on operational efficiencies to better serve our customers with better products and services that contribute to their success. I am confident that this sets us up for better performance in 2023.
Looking forward, there is a lot of economic uncertainty. But rather than dwelling on the uncertainty, our team is focused on what we can control by deeper relationships with our customers, asking prospective customers for their business, being prudent with our capital and not varying from our underwriting philosophy to achieve loan growth.
I’m proud of the honor of Newsweek’s Best Bank in Kansas in the under $10 billion category for 2023. We were also recognized for the third year in a row by the Wichita Business Journal as one of the best places to work based on employee survey data.
I’ll let Eric talk you through our financial results.
Eric Newell
Thank you, Brad. And good morning. Last night, we reported net income of $11.6 million or $0.72 per diluted share. Noninterest income, excluding the $422,000 gain on the branch sale in the fourth quarter was $7.9 million, down $1.1 million linked quarter.
Noninterest expenses less merger costs increased linked quarter to $35.2 million.
We calculate core EPS to be $0.70 per diluted share.
To reconcile GAAP earnings to core earnings this quarter removed merger expenses of $68,000 and gain on branch sale of $420,000.
On Page 6 of the investor deck, we added a new visual to show the impact of our solar tax program. For the total year, we added $811,000 to net income. The timing of the benefit in tax provision and the cost of partnership expense is determined by when we entered into the tax investment versus when the project is placed in this service. Importantly, we expect to adopt accounting for investments and tax credit structures using the proportional amortization method which moves the tax credit expense currently and noninterest expense to the tax line and removes this noise.
Late in December, we learned of a tax credit that we had invested in May 2022 would be delayed, not being placed into service in the calendar year of 2022 as we originally forecasted. That had the effect of adversely impacting the tax provision in the fourth quarter, which is a true-up for the full year. We expect this project to be placed into service early in 2023.
Our GAAP net income includes a release through provision for credit loss of $151,000. While we expect softening in the broader economy in 2023, we have not seen economic trends in our markets that are of specific concern and more importantly, we have not seen any decline in asset quality trends in our portfolio.
While we continue to have qualitative reserves set aside for this uncertainty, the modest release represents improvement in our asset quality and reserves we had previously set aside for specific credits that our special assets team have fully resolved and the credits are no longer on our balance sheet. The December 31 coverage of ACL to loans is 1.38%.
I’ll stop here for a moment and let John talk us through asset quality for the quarter. John?
John Creech
Thanks, Eric. Credit performance for the quarter was again strong, seeing improvement across all categories. Special mention loans declined from $35 million at the beginning of the year to $8 million at quarter end. Special mention loans improved $1 million for the quarter. Delinquencies over 30 days past due were $1.3 million lower, ending the quarter at $6 million.
Nonaccrual loans declined $5.5 million, finishing the quarter at 0.53% of total loans.
I’m most proud of [indiscernible] and Brett Reber, our General Counsel, for working together to reduce OREO to $600,000, excluding branches, our lowest level in a decade. Nonperforming assets declined $11.5 million to $18 million on December 31. The majority of our nonaccrual loans were acquired via bank acquisitions.
Net charge-offs for the quarter were $501,000.
Rising rates inflation and economic uncertainty continue to be a concern. At the same time, consumer liquidity levels and employment have not yet returned to historically normal levels. The credit card portfolio is relatively new and has not yet produced consumer losses that one would expect in a downturn. We continue to have relatively low rates of overdrafts and overdraft-related charge-offs.
Unemployment rates in our largest two markets were less than 3% at year-end. At the end of the quarter, loans to homebuilders were only $28 million. Most of our homebuilders continue to have strong liquidity or good secondary sources of repayment.
Declining commodity prices and drier conditions are a concern for farmers. The war in Ukraine is providing a floor for green producers. Cattle prices have pushed upward with a favorable outlook for 2023. Our hotel portfolio has performed well following the pandemic. Travel resurgence is providing a good tailwind for the lodging sector. About 7.5% of our loan portfolio is income-producing office and commercial properties.
All newer commercial IPRE loans have been financed with comfortable loan values and debt yields. The Midwest appears to have less issues getting employees into the office than the rest of the country. Equity Bank, for example, never went to a remote or hybrid environment as all employees remained in the office throughout the pandemic.
Since fiscal year-end 2019, our Texas ratio has declined from a high of 14% and to 3% at year-end while regulatory capital increased from $348 million to $588 million. During the same period, our ACL has increased from a low of $12 million to $46 million and covers nonaccrual loans by 260%.
Our bankers remain vigilant on the credit front, and we have been successful with our loan pricing strategy. While the Midwest economy remains strong, we anticipate and are prepared for more difficult conditions.
I’ll turn it over to Craig for a discussion on production.
Craig Anderson
Thanks, John. Loan growth in the quarter, excluding PPP and branch sales was $56.8 million or 6.9% annualized. Loan growth in the commercial and commercial real estate portfolios was 9.25% annualized. We continue to successfully originate loans at higher interest rates, and we are seeing higher yields as a result of nearly 60% of our loan portfolio having adjustable rates.
During the fourth quarter, the yield in the loan portfolio increased 50 basis points to 5.59%. Cost of interest-bearing deposits increased 45 basis points to 105 basis points in the quarter. Our pipeline stands at $600 million today. And as John said, we continue to exercise reasonable caution in terms and conditions on new and renewal loans.
Noninterest income of $8.3 million was down $1.1 million quarter-over-quarter when excluding gain on sale of the branch realized in the fourth quarter of $422,000. Service revenue with the exception of mortgage banking held relatively consistent during the quarter, while the benefit of previous acquisitions to noninterest income as well as the declining mortgage production environment drove the quarterly decline.
We are seeing positive momentum in our health savings and trust and wealth management divisions and expect further positive contribution to noninterest income in 2023. Eric?
Eric Newell
Net interest income totaled $42 million in the fourth quarter, increasing from $41.9 million in the linked quarter. We continue to benefit from the rising interest rate environment, with net interest margin increasing five basis points linked quarter to 3.67%.
Turning to Page 8 of the slide deck, you can see the composition of the change in net interest income, which benefited from an increase in the yield on earning assets, offset by the increase in the cost of interest-bearing liabilities. We benefited 10 basis points from purchase accounting in the fourth quarter, up one basis point linked quarter but above our expectation going forward.
Noninterest expense categories increasing from the third quarter included salaries and benefits, advertising and other expenses. Salaries and benefits increased 3.5% linked quarter attributable to lower job vacancy rates, which will incrementally improve our service and sales to our customers.
Advertising expenses increased from the third quarter, mainly attributed to our direct banking platform. As a reminder, our direct bank strategy is designed to meet our deposit needs while helping keep our deposit betas lower in our nondirect channels. Other expenses include our tax credit partnership amortization in the fourth quarter totaling $1.9 million compared to $1.4 million in the third quarter.
Our outlook slide includes an updated view for 2023. We do not include future rate hikes. Our forecast still includes the effects of lagging deposit rates. Moderating the impact of higher deposit rates will be an emphasis on relationships to drive noninterest-bearing accounts. Before taxed $1 billion of loan portfolio cash flows in 2023, with a weighted average yield of 6.75%, which is 63 basis points below our current origination yields, as well as a successful deployment of cash flows of the investment portfolio into the loan portfolio, which has about a 500 basis point spread.
In the fourth quarter, noninterest-bearing deposits declined due to expected seasonality from our commercial and municipal portfolios and further reduction in customers’ excess liquidity. As Brad mentioned, our sales teams have renewed efforts to focus on building and acquiring new relationships, which would have the effect of increasing noninterest-bearing deposits for total funding. Our provision is forecasted to be 20 basis points to average loans. This is a more optimistic view than the current consensus, mainly because of our existing coverage level to loans, the lack of recognized losses and a previous qualitative reserve build for recognizing economic uncertainty.
We expect a higher level of advertising expense in 2023 to support our deposit acquisition efforts. Though efforts are underway to introduce products and services that we anticipate will reduce the cost of customer acquisition. Opportunities that potentially result in positive operating leverage includes technology products and services we’ve been working on through 2022 that will allow for better experience for our customers, improved revenue and incrementally reduce expenses through improved efficiencies.
Brad?
Brad Elliott
Our exceptional employees are focused on core banking services in 2023. Developing relationships with prospective clients and broadening relationships with current customers. Checking account growth and high-quality credit origination remains top of mind. We met with several banks in the fourth quarter at the beginning of this year as well, discussing their options of whether it’s a good time and having low liquidity and in a high rate interest environment, that Equity Bank would be a good upstream merger partner for them. Those discussions will continue. Our performance through 2022 sets us up for success in 2023. We and we are excited for the future.
And with that, we’re happy to take your questions.
Question-and-Answer Session
Operator
Thank you. [Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Jeff Rulis with D.A. Davidson. You may proceed.
Jeff Rulis
Thanks. Good morning, all. Question on the loan growth side, a bit of a softball, I guess you guys are sort of pointing to kind of mid-single digit in 2023. Just interested in kind of the constraints there; I mean is it – I bet it’s a bit of mix of demand you’re seeing, appetite for risk on your own side and the ability to fund that growth. But kind of that the pressure points would be interested in just how you characterize loan growth in the coming year and what you’re looking for there?
Brad Elliott
Yes. So I think there’s a lot of loan opportunities out there, Jeff. And – so we’re just trying to make sure that we’re balancing the ability to put on things that make sense from an interest rate standpoint. We haven’t – we don’t need to or haven’t stretched our credit underwriting. And so there’s lots of opportunities out there. You can grow a lot faster.
The question is, can we get that type of loan growth and keep a interest rate that we want for our balance sheet because we have a viewpoint that we think that rates might continue to keep rising. And so we can’t be locking in rates now on the asset side that aren’t going to reprice in a very near term. And so we’re just being moderate on that from the standpoint that we want to make sure we can originate things that fit our interest rate bucket and in the same sense, are prudent for us to do. But there’s lots of lending opportunities out there, that’s not the issue.
Eric Newell
Jeff, this is Eric. On the period-to-period, so year-end to year-end loan growth, we’re forecasting around 7% to 8%. It might seem a little softer in the forecast slide because that’s average balance.
Jeff Rulis
That’s helpful. Thanks Eric. And maybe while I got you, Eric; on the margin, do you have the average for the month of December? Just trying to figure out what – how that compares to the full quarter average?
Eric Newell
I don’t have the December average in front of me. I would say December probably is a little softer than the quarter just due to the deposit beta that we experienced in the month of December, which you can actually see on Slide 9 of our deck. That’s a newer disclosure for us where we broke down the components of yield and cost and added to cumulative betas for loans. And it says deposits, and that’s total deposits not just interest-bearing. But you can see for deposits, we had a cumulative beta of 16% in Q4 and then a 20% beta in December.
Jeff Rulis
Got you. Yes. I guess looking at the outlook on margin too, it’s kind of range-bound in Q1, maybe to the downside a little bit, and then for the full year, a little lower. So I appreciate it.
Maybe one last one, Brad, just wanted to circle back to your commentary on having discussions with partnerships of other banks. I guess is that picked up a bit. Trying to get a sense for relative more banks coming out of the weeds to say, let’s partner up? Just interested in the a little more color there? Thanks.
Brad Elliott
Yes. I think we’re – I think it’s been a fairly quiet period. And so the conversations we’ve had have been – the requests have been more prevalent in the last 60 days than they were in the prior 90 or 120 days. So I would say those conversations are actually picking up. I think this time of the year always picks up steam a little bit because people get their year-end numbers done. And so they get their packets together to come to market. So it will be an interesting spring for us, I think, because I think there’s going to be some opportunities there. And so what do we want to do and how do we skin those things, and we’ve got some creative ways that that we can deal, I think, with AOCI. And so we’re ready to start having those conversations.
Jeff Rulis
Okay. Appreciate it. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you, one moment for questions. Our next question comes from Andrew Liesch with Piper Sandler. You may proceed.
Andrew Liesch
Hey guys. Good morning. I wanted to touch on, I guess, the margin guide not having any rate hikes built into there? It just seems like with some of the repricing of the beta on the deposit side, but there’s still an upward bias even with a 25 basis point rate hike. Is that still the case? Or has it gotten to the point where it should be pretty neutral now?
Eric Newell
I would say with 25 basis points movement we’re probably looking between zero and 2 basis points of expansion on NIM.
Andrew Liesch
Got it. All right. That’s helpful. Then on the mortgage front, obviously, that line item has been under pressure here for a few quarters. If I look at where it’s been the last couple of quarters, is that a good place to build off for your 2023 outlook? Or do you think maybe the market you’re in a little bit stronger?
Eric Newell
Yes. We – what we did, Andrew, is we looked at the second half of 2022 actual, and we use – if you annualize that, that’s pretty close to our expectation for full year 2023.
Andrew Liesch
Got you. Let’s see. No, I think that covers all the questions I have. Everything else has been answered. So thanks.
Operator
Thank you, one moment for questions. Our next question comes from Damon DelMonte with KBW. You may proceed.
Damon DelMonte
Hey good morning guys. How’s it going today?
Eric Newell
Good, Damon.
Damon DelMonte
Good. So just a quick question on the credit and the outlook. Great commentary and color that was provided in the prepared remarks, the reserve, I think is pretty healthy, around $1.38. And just kind of wondering what your thoughts are on maintaining that level as we go through 2023 and kind of what you would expect for net charge-offs and kind of how we can kind of use that to triangulate into a loan loss provision as we look out over the next few quarters?
Eric Newell
I’ll let John talk about environment, and I can bring it back to the financials.
John Creech
The environment for us from a credit quality standpoint, it’s kind of difficult to characterize because you know what the headwinds look like. But our two largest markets, as we said on the call have 3% unemployment still. If you look at IPR, office and commercial, people in the Midwest are in the office and working, it doesn’t have those headwinds to the degree that the rest of the country does. You look at what we’re seeing in our portfolio and how we’re monitoring it and past dues remain low, overdrafts remain low. They’re almost abnormally low. The borrowing base compliance; we look at borrowing bases; the compliance with the borrowing base is good.
Our loan covenant compliance and monitoring, we’re not providing a lot of waivers. We’ve got favorable compliance with our borrowing bases. Borrower levels of liquidity remains strong. We’re continuing to see borrowers have strong level of liquidity. And what I hear when I look at the economy and listen to our other earnings calls, particularly from the larger banks is that the expectation is kind of muted. So from a credit cost standpoint, it seems odd that we sort of see the continuance of the trend we’ve had for the last year.
Eric Newell
So Damon, when you put all that together from a budgeting perspective, we still look at 20 basis points on average loans for provisioning. But when you listen to John and I could see us coming in lower than that based on what we’re seeing today in the economic environment and what we’re seeing in our portfolio, that certainly could change over the year based on our current coverage and our current credit quality from an ACL point of view, I think that qualitative aspects of the ACL taking into account that uncertainty. But the quantitative are really showing the lack of loss that we have flowing through our model.
Damon DelMonte
Got it. Okay, that’s helpful. I appreciate that color. And then with regard – just kind of a technical question here, but with regards to the impact on the tax rate this quarter because of the timing which related to the solar credit. So should we anticipate like the low end of your 14% to 16% range in the first quarter because you get a bigger benefit? Or is that just embedded in the overall guidance?
Eric Newell
That’s embedded in the overall forecast.
Damon DelMonte
Got it. Okay, all right. That’s all that I had for now. Thank you very much.
Operator
Thank you, one moment for questions. Our next question comes from Terry McEvoy with Stephens. You may proceed.
Terry McEvoy
Good morning everyone.
Eric Newell
Good morning.
Brad Elliott
Good morning, Terry.
Terry McEvoy
I guess we’ve talked about the deposit betas were below the industry last year, and that was the playbook that you talked about. I guess my question is what deposit betas are you using in your margin outlook? And if we do get a couple of rate hikes, how would that impact the beta assumption?
Eric Newell
Right now, we’re using a terminal beta of 40% in our budgeting for 2023. I don’t know if continued rate hikes would alter that assumption at this point, that is something that we talk about in our asset liability committee every month, and we’ll continue to monitor that.
Terry McEvoy
Thanks. And maybe as a follow-up, maybe could you discuss how you’re using the digital bank as an overall funding tool?
Eric Newell
Yes. So the Digital Bank are also brilliant bank, our direct bank channel is a vehicle for us to raise deposits, and that is a market rate, and it helps us focus our efforts in raising deposits in that channel versus our core markets where we do have conversations with our customers on rate, but it reduces the potential cannibalization of deposits and repricing of deposits there.
Terry McEvoy
Okay. Maybe one last one on capital management slide, was it 18; talked about the TCE target at 8.5%, it was 7% at the end of the year. How does that come into play as you think about additional or further buyback activity?
Eric Newell
We – management and the board talk about the buyback each time we meet and we take into account our current expectation for the upcoming year. What we’re seeing in the economic and operating environment. In the most recent quarter we did buy back some shares, but not at a pace that we had in earlier quarters, and I think that was due to us wanting to gain some more certainty on our view of 2023. Now that we have that, I think you’ll see us back in the market here in the beginning of the year, and we’re – our constrained factor right now is retained earnings. So we want to make sure that we are within a certain percentage, call it, 60% to 70% payout and not higher than that.
Brad Elliott
So said differently, Terry; we look at TCE, but TCE, we look at minus AOCI. So when we’re doing our analysis we are very comfortable that the AOCI is going to come back. And we know it’s going to come back mostly or almost always going to come back by the end of 2025. So we look at it minus that, and so that’s not going to be a restraining factor for us in buying back shares.
Terry McEvoy
Okay. Understood. Thanks for taking my questions and appreciate all the details in the prepared remarks. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. And I’m not showing any further questions at this time. This concludes today’s conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.
Be the first to comment