42 Comments

  1. Sir, you are extremely bright and I say that after nearly 45 years trading and investing. However, you have made a very fundamental mistake in your example using heikin-ashi. Namely, that the chart that you "have not cherry picked" is a poor example of the indicator under review and thus, you are being whipsawed and I agree you would lose a great deal of money during the time you are being whipsawed. In short, you would be best served using a stochastic or another oscillator during the sideways movement. But, what if you choose a TRENDING stock and heikin-ashi? Then, since I use it ONLY as an entry vehicle with trending stocks that are also above their moving average, it has proven to be highly effective and very profitably. Bottom line: Ya don't use a saw to hammer a nail, ya use a hammer and visa-versa. If you get a free moment, I challenge you to put out a new video using a trending stock, ETF, etc. and due justice to a great entry indicator and more importantly to your viewers of which I am and will remain a subscribed viewer. Thank you for all that you do for so many!

  2. AMAZING VIDEO VP.. I'VE BEEN LISTENING TO YOUR PODCASTS, I'VE WORKED THROUGH MOST OF BABYPIPS NOW I'M ON THIS MARATHON OF WATCHING YOUR VIDEOS FOR 7 HOURS A DAY AND TESTING THINGS OUT ON THE DEMO, I TOOK A FEW DAYS OFF FROM WORK JUST TO DO THIS, AND WILL DO 6 MONTHS TO 1 YEAR ON DEMO AS YOU SUGGESTED.. YOU ARE INCREDIBLE MAN…. I HOPE GOD REPAYS YOU FOR ALL YOUR EFFORT AND ALL YOU HAVE DONE FOR ALL OF US… YOU MAKE THINGS SIMPLER BRO… GOD BLESS YOU— SHOUT OUT FROM LONDON.

  3. I can’t imagine how good your protocol must be after ten years. Every day mine gets a little better but that’s only because I found your channel. I owe you VP!

  4. I have never made a comment on a trading article before but you have irritated me enough to do so now, especially with the "Cave man" comment. I have been successfully using Heiken Ashi for years. I'm sorry to say that you simply neither understand it nor how to use it. You say nothing about the significance of the size of the bodies of the bars, the size and side of the tails (Above, below or both) and how you can use that information to both enter and leave trades. Of course, it should not be used on its own, but neither should any other indicator. If you are going to publish articles, it might be a good idea to know what you are talking about.

  5. Wow waste of 5 minutes. The heiken ashi is lousy to enter but worth it to maintain the positoin and to exit. No explanation at all about why he is saying that. Just another con artist trying to tell you he knows something you don;t know and wants you to pay him money for his wisdom

  6. Hi all. If somebody wants to change any parameter of this or another indicators, just leave me here contact. I´m trader programmer so I can extend/create you anything you can explain.

  7. A lot of fools questioning his validity as a legit trader….show YOUR accounts and how grand your numbers are or shit the f*ck up with your weak comments…taking up oxygen with your jealousy…keep it up VP, your killing it.

  8. cant agree less with your assessment about HA, getting out when color changes, really. I dont think that you ever even traded with HA…its horrible to say what you said, I would say swing trader would be way more successful with HA than any other candle charts , no need any other indicator, which I think nobody needs anyway just in case if you feel better using one, just use the MACD without the bars showing only the lines, no tweaking necessary, KISS ..keep it simple, more you try to find thats you think it will help, it does not believe me, I learn from real trader, indies are just a distraction makes you, do crazy decisions and its already hart to make money with FX follow the trend the trend is your friend..all said

  9. Is it standard that you can take money off the table during a trade? you mention that when you are ahead in a trade and winning, you can take half off of the table, take your winnings , change your stop loss to buy or sell point and continue the trade risk free. I really want to add this to my strategy on my practice account(s) but the two brokers i've tried this on haven't allowed the feature.

  10. Sorry, but HA is so much more than you portray. I use it for entry, close, and managing the trade. Granted, I only use it for 4+ hour forex trades. For copper intraday trades, HA indeed failes miserably, and only a simple price LINE works for me. HA is the only indicator I use, and if used properly (with price line for true price action), can be very successful. And no, I DO NOT use its trend colors to make trades, it's entry and exit points go beyond candle colors.

    You are simply giving people misguided information, regarding HA, in this video.

    My MoM growth is all I need to see HA's potential and I couldn't be happier. But, I trade the first two hours of copper without using HA – just to point out that I was taught without indicators – and HA is the only indicator I can use with total confidence in forex.

  11. Damn, ended up pausing this one…lol… stopped the recent prop trader upload for being so advnce for me for now, and pausing this one =))… gtta watch the links first…

  12. fabulous video …….so deceiving using ha …………renko alongside normal candles with a volume divergence indicator and vp ssl indicator 90% win rate …..simple really

  13. Hi,

    My name is Sigal, from Israel.

    Sorry in advance about English …

    I was exposed to the trade only about six months ago. I signed up for a course (in stocks) and then micro-contracted training of indexes and commodities.

    Despite all the tools the course provides, something was missing …

    The feeling was that all of this description didn't quite fit when I thought deeply about what was being explained and the pace of daily trading was fast for me.

    I started searching the web for completeness and extension of what I had already heard,

    My desire was to isolate the "background noise" and to study the field as a new profession is systematically studied (since I am from another field in the profession, I studied chemistry / quality and safety).

    And I want to thank you for the very special videos. You're the only one who says "the king is naked" – thank you.

  14. Heikin Ashi can be a very accurate indication of a trade confirmation set up and entry if used over two time frames and even at small time frame levels. Example: 8 min timeframe shows what looks like a doji heikin ashin whilst the 4 min time frame shows a strong (flat bottomed or topped depending on direction) heikin ashi. Good for continuation and reversals. If you want to have a 2:1 ratio trade I'd suggest using one time frame as a set up and another time frame one eighht smaller as an entry. Have all your charts set to increasing scales multiple of .. so.. 1 – 2 – 4 – 8 – 16 – 32 etc….. which means that the larger time frames are always closing when a smaller time frame is closing. This tells you what the actual noise is, in the market. If your platform dosen't allow you to have multi timeframes up at the same time.. ditch it. It's like having one wing mirror on the wrong side and another on the roof of the car .. you need to see the traffic in all directions before entering and when in a trade too…… unless you have enough capital that you just ride out your losses without knowing why they were losses. 🙂 Which is just gambling.

  15. hey man watched lots of videos of yours. they are amazing. one request please share the list of top 100 indicators(not the settings). please do it so that we(your followers) can test them and find out which ones work for us.🙏🙏

  16. Thanks for the videos, blog and podcasts VP, I'm taking it slow. Would it not be the case to just check the Heiken Ashi candle just once at the end of day play, as the new candle forms, as opposed to always having to keep an eye on it for an exit? Or am I missing something? Like Pips.

    Thanks Again really great stuff!

  17. I've had some good experience with the HA indicator.  Made over $580 overnight in two trades.  Of course, I don't just depend on just one indicator but used two other indicators to compliment and I didn't place my stop at my buy entry, but gave it room to breathe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*